Advocacy

Tis the season… to abandon our philosophy?

Well, it is December. The Christmas season is well and truly underway and my Facebook and Pinterest feeds are filled with photos of very clever Christmas craft, decorated rooms and ideas for embracing the festive season with children. Let me begin this post with a disclaimer (probably never a good sign!!) that I love Christmas and think that it can be a really exciting time for children. I have great memories of looking at Christmas lights with my family and doing lots of fun Christmas experiences. 

What bothers me though is that in our attempts to fully embrace the festive spirit, many services and educators appear to abandon their philosophies and subsequently, children’s rights. Services who usually wouldn’t allow a stencil to make it’s way in the front gate all of a sudden have Christmas crafts were every child makes an identical footprint reindeer. Services who usually encourage children to make choices about their play are suddenly urging them to “come and make a present for Mummy”. Services who usually embrace casual, relaxed group times are working hard on Christmas concerts where all of the children are expected to perform. 

The big question…why?

Why do we let the festive season take over our services? Is it not possible to celebrate Christmas in meaningful ways that actually link in with our philosophies? 

Don’t get me wrong – I know this is not happening in every service. Some services are doing truly meaningful things with their children and families and should be applauded for this, but the influx of images on social media tells me it is definitely happening a lot.

I looked back at some photographs of myself at age 4 at our annual Christmas Concert. There I was lined up with 20 other children, all with identical santa beards and hats we had made with paper and cotton balls, singing my heart out. Sure, I was having a great time. But just down from me was a child who clearly was not having a great time, in fact he was miserable. Looking at the photo I do remember this child refusing to sing Christmas songs at preschool and being told he had to join in the concert weather he liked it or not. I like to think we have come a long way in almost 30 years… but have we? I am still seeing children making identical Christmas craft and being coerced into Christmas concerts. And it’s not just Early Childhood Services – on the weekend I watched many children being forced to sit on a strangers lap despite their vocal protests (yes I mean Santa and yes, my children did have their photo taken with him, but it was optional…I am not a total grinch!)

A few years ago I think there was a swing the other way – in an effort to be inclusive of multicultural beliefs, many services abandoned the celebration of Christmas. And while I am not advocating for that, I think there is middle ground to be found. When I was Directing, we ditched the Christmas concert tradition and instead began having a family picnic at the park – a time to be together rather than be on display. One year we had a group of children who did want to perform for their families… they chose to act out Wombat Stew, a story that had been a favourite for months. 
We made lots of materials available and if children wanted to make something they could, if they didn’t – not a problem! Naturally many children came in wanting to make, create, sing and do all things Christmas and as with any other interest, we allowed the children to lead us where they wished to go, providing provocations, materials and support as needed. We opened up a meaningful dialogue with families about our choices and how doing specific craft experiences and forcing children to make gifts really didn’t sit in line with our philosophy nor did it feel like we were sharing a meaningful experience with the children. 

This post really seems to link back to the one I wrote on Mothers Day and I guess the message is much the same. 
By all means celebrate Christmas, but please make it meaningful to the children. Please allow them to still have the right to make choices about their play and their day. 

No Comments

  • Kate S

    Reply

    I wholeheartedly agree. Why too at Christmas do we suddenly only have red and green paint available. We do the family picnic too and it is so lovely. A nice time to relax and spend quality time with children and their families instead of stressing about making sure everyone has a set of bells and is singing along.

    December 1, 2014 at 12:04 pm
  • Lindy T

    Reply

    I can’t agree enough.
    As an Educator I feel the pressure to ‘do’ Christmas with my Puddle Jumpers. Don’t get me wrong it looks nice and I’m sure the parents adore their efforts; but let’s be honest mass produced, identical ‘product’ isn’t what excites anyone.
    I have 3 vastly different beliefs in my Service ( mine being out of main stream) I pay homage to all beliefs by listening to what they talk about.
    One says Crishmas is bad- so we won’t be sending product home with her.
    Another doesn’t ‘Do’ Christmas for personal reasons
    I asked the children what they wanted to do their answer was play with their friends at Day Care. So craft is open ended and not a single Christmas thing in sight.
    The children have spoken and that’s how I feel it should be.

    December 1, 2014 at 1:17 pm
  • Jennifer

    Reply

    I love finding meaningful ways of embracing christmas. I have to, because if it isn’t meaningful then Christmas has a tendancy of swamping us anyway. Go with it! Find what’s important to us in the season – celebrate that and ditch the rest! I celebrate an Advent festival with my community and kinder families each year – this is secular story and a story and simple, crafts linked to the story which celebrate gratitude and simplicity. Starting our journey into Christmas madness with the message that we can keep it simple, and we can find our own meaning in the festive season. Beyond that, you won’t see much about Christmas at my service – possibly some handmade decorations but only if children can make it themselves – and feel like doing it. Not for me the red and green paint. Bring me stories and bring me colour and celebration connection.

    December 1, 2014 at 1:53 pm
  • Rebecca Boyes

    Reply

    Well written Nicole. A great message here. How often have we held a list of children’s names and ticked each one off as we have pulled them away from the playdough to make sure they decorate a card for their parents, in red and green glitter??

    December 6, 2014 at 3:31 am
  • Online Toy Store In Australia

    Reply

    It is a nice post. The information in this article is very useful.

    June 15, 2015 at 8:54 am
  • Jenny Craft

    Reply

    Your post is very informative as I’m Mother living in the Sydney. I found many interesting things in your post.

    July 9, 2015 at 9:21 pm
  • Sarah

    Reply

    Great and timely post (for this year as well!). I think meaningful experiences are probably the most important element of growing up – and also exploring what things are meaningful to OTHER families / kids. Integrating aspects of multi-cultural celebrations is great too. But at the end of the day, if they want to study a butterfly, or play with water in the sandpit, why not, just because it’s December!!

    December 7, 2015 at 1:48 pm

REPLY A MESSAGE